Megan Fox & Jeremy Clarkson's mental health gaffes

Megan Fox and Jeremy Clarkson have been named as the celebs who made the worst mental health gaffes of 2011, by the national charity Rethink Mental Illness. 

We have released our annual list of the five most offensive comments made about mental illness, by people in the public eye this year, alongside a list of five ‘mental health heroes’ of 2011.

“It is a negative character, as she suffered from personality disorders and was bipolar. I do not want to attract this kind of negative energy in my life."

- Megan Fox on the Marylin Monroe tattoo she had removed

Rethink Mental Illness’s gaffes of the year: 2011

Megan Fox Rethink Mental Illness - Mental Health Gaffes of 20111.    Megan Fox, Actress

Had her tattoo of Marilyn Monroe removed when she discovered the Hollywood icon had mental health problems.

Fox told Italian magazine Amica: "I'm removing it. It is a negative character, as she suffered from personality disorders and was bipolar. I do not want to attract this kind of negative energy in my life."

Rethink Mental Illness CEO Paul Jenkins said: “Fox’s comments are insensitive and reinforce the myth that having an illness such as bipolar disorder is some kind of personal failing or a sign of weakness. I very much doubt Fox would have made a statement like this if Monroe had been affected by a physical illness such as cancer.”

Jeremy Clarkson Rethink Mental Illness - Mental Health Gaffes of 20112.    Jeremy Clarkson, TV presenter

In December, Clarkson complained in his newspaper column that people who commit suicide on railways cause ‘immense’ disruption for commuters by delaying their journeys.

Jane Harris, associate director of communications for Rethink Mental Illness said: “Criticising people who are such extreme distress that they end their own life, is a new low even for Clarkson. If he feels so strongly about suicide, perhaps he should channel his anger into campaigning for better mental health services, rather than attacking people who may have struggled for many years with a mental illness.

Jameela Jamil Rethink Mental Illness - Mental Health Gaffes of 20113.    Jameela Jamil, TV presenter

Tweeted that Catherine Zeta-Jones’s diagnosis of Bipolar disorder was down to the menopause.

On the day the Hollywood actress revealed to the world she had been diagnosed with Bipolar disorder, the T4 presenter tweeted: 'Catherine Zeta-Jones has just been admitted to rehab for bipolar disorder. I GUARANTEE it's just the menopause! Makes 40+ crazy.’

Paul Jenkins said: “Although Jamil may have intended this as a joke, it was in very poor taste. People who are brave enough to be open about their mental illness, should be commended, not ridiculed.”

4.    Philip Davies, Conservative backbench MP

Said people with a mental illness should work for less than minimum wage.

Philip Davies, the MP for Shipley told the House of Commons in June that people with mental health problems should be able to work for less than minimum wage in order to get a foot in the door of employment because they ‘can’t be as productive’.

Paul Jenkins said: “To suggest that the answer to employment discrimination is to cut the wages of those already facing disadvantage is seriously misguided. His comments are an insult to anybody who has ever had a mental health problem.”

5.    Geoffrey Boycott, cricket commentator

Joked in March that cricketer Michael Yardy's depression might have been caused by Boycott's criticism of his bowling.

Paul Jenkins said: “Boycott’s thoughtless and crass comments reveal an out-dated attitude. He seems to be missing the point that depression is a serious illness, it’s not about being a bit stressed at work. The one encouraging thing about the whole incident was how quickly and widely his comments were condemned. It shows that attitudes are shifting, and views like this are becoming much less acceptable.”


Rethink Mental Illness’s heroes of the year: 2011

Catherine Zeta-Jones Rethink Mental Illness - Mental Health Heroes of 20111.    Catherine Zeta-Jones

Revealed she is receiving treatment for bipolar disorder.

Mark Davies, Director of communications for Rethink Mental Illness said: “It is to her credit that she described her illness truthfully. The stigma that still surrounds mental illness often means that people stay silent and try to cope alone. When people such as Catherine Zeta-Jones speak out it makes a huge difference to the millions of other people facing mental illness as it shows they are not alone.”

2.    Rebecca Front

Admitted on Twitter that she experiences panic attacks and encouraged other celebrity tweeters to follow her lead and reveal their mental health issues.

Davies said: “Front opened up one of the biggest conversations of the year around mental health through this one simple action. The outpouring that followed highlighted the power celebrities and social media have as a force for positive change.”

3.    Georgia Taylor

Played Dr Ruth Winter in Casualty who developed mental illness and was sectioned.

Davies said: “Taylor’s portrayal of mental illness was sensitive and brought the issue to a mass prime-time audience. We had an overwhelmingly positive response from our members and supporters, many of whom had been through similar experiences to the character.” 

4.    Frank Bruno

Spoke openly about being sectioned for the Time to Change Campaign.

Davies said: “Since his mental health crisis in 2003, Bruno has become one of the most open celebrities in the UK, when it comes to mental illness. He has campaigned tirelessly to end mental health discrimination through the Time to Change Campaign and has brought comfort to many thousands of people.”

5.    Danny Cipriani

Former England rugby star, Danny Cipriani, revealed he sought counselling after being affected by a period of severe depression.

Davies said: “It was very courageous of Danny to be so open about his experiences with depression. His honesty will have given courage to many others who may be afraid to talk openly about their mental health, and will act as a source of strength to those who suffer in silence.

“This year saw a real turning point for sport and mental health more generally, with Jonny Wilkinson and Michael Yardy also speaking out about their experiences of depression. The fact they both felt able to do this, is perhaps a sign that things are changing in the macho world of sport.”

Comments

Please note: Rethink accepts no responsiblity for the content of comments in the blog.
1. At 11:44 AM on 09 February 2012 Anne Marie Silbiger wrote:

Depression and anxiety

In my own words I have tried to explain to members of my family who struggle to understand what I am going through. I also struggle with my own honesty about my illness. Anyway this is what I wrote. ''Depression is eating away at me like a tapeworm. Feeding on the negativity and it feels like it is winning. I lash out because I am scared. Anxiety is also part of the illness which in turn causes irritability. I am sad too because I feel helpless and pathetic. Powerless to stop the march of the soldiers of doom across my brain and annihilate any spirit I have left. I feel warped, disfigured and melted. Like a Dali painting. Time goes but I sit frozen hoping for some flicker of calm or happiness to ignite what was there before and bring me roaring back to life. I am not me.''
2. At 07:35 PM on 02 February 2012 Rose wrote:

Employment

I have suffered from mental health problems for a number of years and have found that this does make it difficult to get paid employment, partly because many jobs would be very hard to cope with, but also because prospective employers doubt the capabilities of people with poor mental health. However, I'm sure that many sufferers would like to be given a chance to prove themselves, and that with the right support and the prospect of earning a fair wage, they could be a valuable addition to the workforce. The only work I was able to secure after being treated for depression and anxiety was cleaning. Nevertheless I took the job to help boost our family income, and have kept it up for nearly six years, doing 20 hours a week employed by the council. Many people have commented that my work is of a very high standard and their appreciation of what I do has helped keep me at it and increased my self-respect. However, I would have felt insulted and devalued had I been told I would get paid less than "well" people to do this job! Philip Davies comment should him to be completely ignorant of mental health problems. As an MP, he really should educate himself about such issues, since many of his constituents will undoubtedly be affected by mental ill health at some time.
3. At 07:28 PM on 26 January 2012 Cllr Krishna Lathia-James wrote:

crass comments re mental health

It is very disturbing when people in positions of power belittle mental health issues. They are the real heros of this world and I meet plenty of them doing their work quietly helping fellow survivors and sufferers because n matter what people say for some people it is a daily struggle. About time we gave medal to survivors of mental health conditions.
4. At 07:42 PM on 30 December 2011 marion sherwood wrote:

Mental Health

Rethink is the right name I think to attract response from those who will not review or refuse to address inner or outward experiences of mental issues surrounding their own personal wellbeing Reflection I believe on the past traumas related to how friends family and we ourselves deal with the sensitive issues and emotions of illness and conditions related to Mental Health will enable us to take off the rose colored glasses. We all need to try using our ears eyes and brains the way they were designed for to... evoke human compassion and fellow feeling to suffering....dont expect any help yourself if you made it too hard on others ....ignoring and ducking the issues will reveal our anti gens are not as powerful and resistant as we imagined ....let us all help to grow a healthy society by caring and sharing problems that stop us smiling at Life's pleasures instead of ignoring mental health.
5. At 11:52 AM on 29 December 2011 caroline wrote:

Yeah Megan

because having a tatoo removed because of negative energy you might attract is like really rational
6. At 10:12 AM on 29 December 2011 JENNY wrote:

gaffes of the year 2011

Interesting some of the comments, ignorance? Maybe but some of them such as Clarksons make me wonder about their mental health. As for the MP WOW!! How bad is that!! Has he any clue? Did he think maybe people with mental health problems may be better workers? No of course he didn't because of his own ignorance. I worry about the state of our country when supposedly educated elected representatives speak like this. Maybe Mr Davis should be invited to work for a week within mental health to enlighten him.

Post a comment

Please include your name and your email address. Your email will not appear with the comment, but whatever name you provide will.

Comments are moderated, and will appear when Rethink approves them. Rethink cannot guarantee your blog comment will be published.

Required
Required
Required
Maximum characters 1600
 
 
If you wish to remove a comment that you posted on this blog then please email online.team@rethink.org