Why did you kill my dad? My own response

Topics: Siblings, Stigma and discrimination

I have just watched Julian Hendy’s documentary, 'Why Did You Kill My Dad?' I have now stopped crying, I have read some articles about this on the internet and it has all left me feeling incredibly sad, sick, frustrated, worried and angry.

I am sad because this was just real people, telling real stories. These murders happened and the documentary gave us real insight into just how devastating these events were. The documentary showed the cases through the eyes of the victims’ families and friends. There is another story here too, the suffering and the battles of the families and friends of the people who committed the killings. I am sure that their stories would make me have very similar emotions.

I am sick and frustrated because I have seen the system in action for many years as a sister of someone who suffers from a severe mental illness. All of the things raised are the same things that service users, carers and families raise constantly and consistently every day. They are the same things that are raised in every review, consultation process, complaint that I have ever been involved in.

I am worried because, as Dolly Sen’s message in her blog states, I too hope that viewers will hear the film's message: that recommendations must be implemented; that families must be listened to and that mental health services must improve. I hope that viewers do not just come away with the message that people with mental illness are dangerous.  I hope that they understand the harrowing cases represented in the documentary only represent the small number of cases. I hope that viewers understand that actually there about a million people in the UK with bipolar disorder, schizophrenia and personality disorder and that they are law abiding citizens.

I am angry because the fundamentals of the services available to people with mental illness, despite all of these lessons, just doesn’t change. I would like to add that I believe that the day-to-day stories behind many of the people with a serious mental illness, who never have and never will hurt anyone, and their families and friends would be as emotional, as full of hopelessness, as frustrating, as helpless and as full of regret. That the stories from these people and from their families and friends would spell out the same messages and lessons that need to be learnt. Mental Health services must not only improve in my opinion, but must change radically and start taking responsibility.

These issues just need to be sorted out not just as a way of trying to prevent this violence, but so that the majority of us with experience of being involved with mental health services either directly or indirectly can see our loved one supported properly by services. So that we can get back to the business of being sisters, mothers, husbands, wives, children.

Comments

Please note: Rethink accepts no responsiblity for the content of comments in the blog.
1. At 10:18 AM on 27 April 2010 Victoria Simmons wrote:

I agree also

I am really sorry and shocked to hear your story about your brother. How on earth can any council justify making a mentally ill person homeless.? Have you written to your MP ?and NHS/ services council with the exact same questions as you have posted above.? They clearly havent done everything they could, because they have effectively thrown a man out on the street who clearly needs some support and guidance. Grounds for sueing, for lack of sufficient medical care and adequate treatment surely.! tho Im not suggesting sueing but merely as a carrot/stick approach asmaking him homeless is putting himself and others further at risk and is obviously of great concern to you. If he has a serious drug or alchohol problem he needs to face up to this and be given proper strong firm guidlines and boundaries and counselling. and that is what the NHS and psychotheraputic services are there for and paid to do. If they thought he was psychotic, enough to be detained, at one point then he obviously has a probelm. However he has to realise this himself. Sometimes reaching rock bottom is the turning point Letting him be homeless without any further medical help or assistance or counselling is highly dangerous to himself, and others, immoral and irresponible. I know there are no perfect answers and people are ultimately repsonsible for themselves and have to realise and recognise they need to change, and ask for help, but they do also need group and community support.
2. At 09:07 PM on 01 April 2010 ian reedman wrote:

cling ons

it ios not so much the deaths caused by mental ill people but people that go on about their problems like ringing up about problems of their own and also other peoples. when u complain u know who your friends are it is common that is why i left rethink and some true friends who left rethink also. so stand on ur own two feet people. sorry about english as i am dsylexic too. i am now much happy person now i left.
3. At 02:10 PM on 23 March 2010 David John wrote:

I agree.

I couldn't agree more. As the brother of someone with a severe mental illness who was sectioned, lost his flat and is now apparently homeless I am sickened by the way the mental health authorities operate. It was them who had my brother sectioned and from then failed totally to do anything to follow it up other than have a social worker assigned to him and a prescription for anti-psychotics. My question is why did the authorities go to all the trouble of having him sectioned then discharged, even though his illness hadn't gone away at all, and then don't follow up on it? They have actually made a very bad situation much, much worse. They will say "we did everything we could, people make their own decisions". Yet someone suffering from severe mental illness isn't capable of making rational decisions. I don't know what the answer is, but I would have a pretty good idea of how to address the system than the current operators.

Post a comment

Please include your name and your email address. Your email will not appear with the comment, but whatever name you provide will.

Comments are moderated, and will appear when Rethink approves them. Rethink cannot guarantee your blog comment will be published.

Required
Required
Required
Maximum characters 1600
 
 
If you wish to remove a comment that you posted on this blog then please email online.team@rethink.org